Wall Street analysts are warming up to Coterra Energy , a stock we bought more shares of just last week when it was firmly out of favor. In recent days, Citigroup, UBS and Wells Fargo all upgraded Coterra to buy-equivalent ratings, highlighting a host of fundamental reasons — including improving capital efficiency — to own the oil-and-gas producer despite volatility in commodity markets. Including its 3% gain Thursday, to over $25 per share, Coterra’s stock is on pace for only its second-positive week in seven. Shares of Coterra entered Thursday’s session down 17% since mid-October, coinciding with a steep swoon in crude oil and natural gas prices. Oversupply concerns have weighed on both commodities in recent weeks, though each traded higher Thursday. West Texas Intermediate crude, the U.S. oil benchmark, soared 4% in afternoon trading, to more than $72 a barrel. U.S. natural gas gained about 1%, to roughly $2.36 per million British thermal units. Coterra is distinct among its exploration-and-production peers because its revenues are split roughly 50-50 between oil and natural gas. The significant exposure to both is one reason why we’ve stayed invested in Coterra, despite pairing back our overall energy exposure this year. “This is one I do want you to own,” Jim Cramer said Thursday. “You don’t get three brokers upgrading a stock all in one week” that often, he added. In the near term, Coterra’s stock may struggle to make a sustained move higher if unusually warm weather persists throughout the winter, meaning there’s less natural gas needed to heat homes and buildings, Jim acknowledged. “But that’s not I bet I want to make. I think you want to be long Coterra,” he said. CTRA YTD mountain Coterra’s year-to-date stock performance. Citigroup kicked off a wave of Coterra upgrades Monday and raised its price target to $30 per share, up from $28. The company’s oil-and-gas operations both “appear ripe” to deliver improved capital efficiency next year, resulting in lower breakevens, Citi analysts wrote in a research note. A breakeven is the commodity price a company needs to profitably drill a new well. “The recent pullback on near term commodity price weakness presents an opportunity in our view” to buy Coterra, the analysts argued — a recommendation that mirrors the contrarian action we took Dec. 6 , when we added to our position at $24.81 per share. Analysts at Wells Fargo and UBS issued their upgrades Thursday. Like Citi, Wells Fargo expressed optimism around Coterra’s efficiency improvements and said the stock trades at a relative discount to its peers, based on 2025 financial estimates. The firm lifted its price target on Coterra to $30 per share, from $29. “Over the past 12 months, [management] has deftly orchestrated a turnaround for the company,” Wells Fargo said, referring to investor concerns about Coterra’s asset write-downs in November 2022, which we had argued were overblown . The more money Coterra is able to make — whether…
Read More: Here’s what’s driving Wall Street’s newfound bullishness on Coterra